Search inside image Countries worldwide commemorate anniversary of Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel | PBS News Visit Get this image on: pictur…
Day: May 12, 2025
Wagner/GRU Role in October 7th?
The hypothesis that the Wagner Group, a Russian private military company, and the GRU, Russia’s military intelligence agency, were involved in the October 7, 2023, Hamas-led attack on Israel stems from allegations and circumstantial claims, primarily raised by Ukrainian sources and echoed in some Western analyses. However, there is no definitive evidence confirming their direct involvement, and the hypothesis remains speculative. Below is a summary of the key points, investigations, and context surrounding this hypothesis:
Key Allegations
-
Wagner Group Training Hamas:
-
The National Resistance Center of Ukraine, citing Belarusian partisans, alleged that Wagner Group mercenaries trained Hamas militants in assault tactics and drone operations, specifically in Africa. These claims suggest Wagner shared expertise in using drones to drop explosives, a tactic seen in the October 7 attack.
-
The Ukrainian Center for National Resistance claimed Wagner fighters, who had moved from Belarus to African countries, provided combat experience to Hamas, enhancing their capabilities for the attack.
-
No non-Ukrainian sources have independently verified these allegations. Other Russian private military companies, such as Vegacy Strategic Services or PMC Redut, have also been mentioned as possible trainers in Syria, but evidence is lacking.
-
-
GRU Involvement:
-
The hypothesis of GRU involvement is largely speculative, based on the sophistication of the attack, which some argue exceeded Hamas’s known capabilities. Blogger Michael Novakhov, for instance, posited that the meticulous planning, technical expertise in electronic warfare, and operational complexity point to a professional intelligence agency like the GRU.
-
Novakhov argues that the GRU’s operational secrecy means evidence is unlikely to surface, but the attack’s scale suggests external support beyond Hamas’s capacity.
-
No concrete evidence links the GRU directly to the attack, and these claims rely on assumptions about Russia’s strategic interests rather than documented proof.
-
-
Russian Strategic Interests:
-
Some analyses suggest Russia could benefit from the attack by diverting Western attention from its war in Ukraine and destabilizing the Middle East to weaken U.S. influence.
-
Russia has maintained ties with Hamas since 2006, hosting its leaders in Moscow and avoiding labeling Hamas as a terrorist organization. This relationship, combined with alleged use of Russian cryptocurrency exchanges like Garantex to fund Hamas, fuels speculation of indirect support.
-
However, Russia’s Foreign Ministry and the Kremlin have denied involvement, and no evidence confirms Moscow’s prior knowledge of the attack.
-
Investigations and Evidence
-
Israeli Investigations:
-
Israeli intelligence failures are well-documented, with the Shin Bet and IDF admitting they underestimated Hamas’s capabilities and ignored warnings of the attack. A 40-page Hamas battle plan, codenamed “Jericho Wall,” was obtained by Israel over a year prior but dismissed as aspirational.
-
Investigations by Shin Bet and the IDF focus on internal failures, such as misjudgments about Hamas’s intentions, overreliance on technology, and poor human intelligence in Gaza. No Israeli reports mention Wagner or GRU involvement.
-
The IDF’s probe into specific incidents, like the Zikim Beach massacre, highlights operational chaos and friendly fire but does not point to foreign actors like Wagner or the GRU.
-
-
International Investigations:
-
The U.S. Justice Department announced a task force (JTF 10-7) to investigate Hamas’s October 7 attack, focusing on the group’s actions and potential support networks. While it examines financing and material support, no public findings have implicated Wagner or the GRU.
-
The International Criminal Court (ICC) is investigating war crimes by Hamas and Israel, but its scope is limited to actions since 2014 and does not specifically address foreign involvement like Wagner or GRU.
-
-
Lack of Conclusive Evidence:
-
Western intelligence, including U.S. officials, has not corroborated claims of Wagner or GRU involvement. A Newsweek report explicitly states there is no evidence of direct Russian involvement, noting Hamas’s long history of operations and Iranian support.
-
Allegations of Wagner’s role are primarily sourced from Ukrainian outlets, which may have a bias to implicate Russia given the ongoing war in Ukraine.
-
The sophistication of the attack, including the use of drones, paragliders, and electronic warfare, is often cited as evidence of external training, but Hamas has developed drone capabilities independently and received support from Iran, a more established ally.
-
Counterarguments
-
Hamas’s Capabilities:
-
Hamas has a history of conducting complex operations, with support from Iran and access to indigenous and Iranian weapons. The group’s “Nukhba forces” and years of planning could account for the attack’s scale without requiring Wagner or GRU involvement.
-
Israeli intelligence failures, including dismissing Hamas’s plans and underfunding Gaza surveillance, allowed the group to execute the attack with surprise, amplifying its impact.
-
-
Iran’s Role:
-
Iran is a more likely external backer, given its long-standing support for Hamas, including funding, weapons, and training. Initial reports and Hamas statements suggest Iranian involvement, though Tehran has denied directing the attack.
-
-
Russian Denials:
-
Russia’s Foreign Ministry and Kremlin have dismissed claims of involvement, and Wagner’s dissolution under Kremlin control reduces the likelihood of independent actions by the group.
-
Current Sentiment and Speculation
-
Posts on X, particularly by user@mikenov
, reflect ongoing speculation about Wagner and GRU involvement, emphasizing the attack’s sophistication as evidence of external support. These posts, however, are opinion-driven and lack primary evidence.
-
The hypothesis gains traction in pro-Ukrainian circles and among those critical of Russia, but it remains unverified by mainstream investigations.
Conclusion
The Hamas-Wagner Group-GRU hypothesis is based on Ukrainian allegations, circumstantial claims about the attack’s sophistication, and Russia’s historical ties to Hamas. While these raise questions about potential indirect support, no credible evidence directly implicates Wagner or the GRU. Israeli and international investigations focus on Hamas’s actions and Israel’s intelligence failures, with Iran as the primary external backer. The hypothesis remains speculative, and further independent reporting is needed to substantiate or refute it. Always approach such claims critically, as geopolitical biases can shape narratives without solid proof.
If you want me to dig deeper into specific aspects, like Russian-Hamas ties or Israeli intelligence failures, let me know!
–
Gemini
Allegations of Wagner and GRU Involvement in October 7th Attack Emerge, Investigations Ongoing
Allegations primarily from Ukrainian sources suggest Russian private military company Wagner Group and Russia’s military intelligence agency GRU may have been involved in training or supporting Hamas ahead of the October 7th attack on Israel.
The hypothesis of Wagner Group and GRU involvement gained traction following claims by Ukrainian intelligence and military officials. These sources, including the National Resistance Center of Ukraine, alleged that Wagner mercenaries provided training to Hamas militants, particularly in assault tactics and the use of small unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) to drop explosives.
Official investigations into the multifaceted failures leading to the October 7th attack are being conducted by multiple entities:
- Israel: The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) and Israeli intelligence agencies are conducting extensive inquiries into the intelligence and operational shortcomings that allowed the attack to occur. Publicly released information from these probes has so far focused on internal miscalculations regarding Hamas’s intentions and capabilities, and the military’s preparedness and response. There has been no official confirmation from the Israeli government or military specifically implicating Wagner or GRU operatives in the direct execution of the attack.
- United States: The U.S. Department of Justice has launched “Joint Task Force October 7” (JTF 10-7) to investigate and prosecute individuals involved in the attacks who committed crimes against Americans, as well as those providing material support to Hamas and its affiliates, including Iranian proxies.
3 While the scope is broad, public announcements have not specifically named Wagner or GRU as direct targets of this investigation in relation to the October 7th attack. U.S. intelligence assessments regarding the attack have largely focused on the failure to anticipate Hamas’s actions. - International Bodies: Human Rights Watch has conducted detailed investigations focusing on war crimes and crimes against humanity committed by Hamas-led groups during the assault.
4 The United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry is also examining the attacks, though its initial findings have focused on the actions of all parties and have not highlighted Wagner/GRU involvement.
While direct, independently verified evidence or official pronouncements from major Western or Israeli intelligence agencies publicly corroborating a command-and-control or operational role for Wagner or GRU in the October 7th attack remain limited, the broader context includes:
- Russia-Hamas Relations: Russia has maintained relations with Hamas, hosting its delegations in Moscow and not designating it as a terrorist organization, unlike many Western countries.
5 - Wagner and GRU Global Activities: Both the Wagner Group (whose leadership was significantly disrupted by the death of Yevgeny Prigozhin and Dmitry Utkin in August 2023 but whose elements reportedly continue to operate under new structures) and the GRU have a documented history of operating in various global hotspots, including the Middle East and Africa, often as instruments of Russian foreign policy and in cooperation with groups aligned with Russian interests. Reports have indicated GRU advisory roles with Houthi rebels in Yemen and Wagner’s alleged supply of an air defense system to Hezbollah.
6
Analysts and commentators continue to scrutinize any potential Russian links to the October 7th attack, but a definitive conclusion on direct Wagner/GRU involvement in its planning and execution remains elusive based on currently available public information from official investigations. The allegations persist, primarily driven by Ukrainian sources and geopolitical analysis, while official inquiries by Israel and its allies have yet to publicly validate this specific hypothesis.
–
The News And Times
2 hrs ago
Articles: Vladimir Putin’s Wagner mercenary group involved in ‘training Hamas terrorists’
Michael Novakhov – SharedNewsLinks℠Vladimir Putin’s Wagner mercenary group involved in ‘training Hamas terrorists’Monday May 12th, 2025 at 1:24 PMDaily Express :: World Feed1 Share…
The News And Times
3 hrs ago
Pope Leo: “Let me, therefore, reiterate today the church’s solidarity with journalists who are imprisoned for seeking and reporting the truth. The precious gift of free speech and of the press must be safeguarded.”
Pope Leo: “Let me, therefore, reiterate today the church’s solidarity with journalists who are imprisoned for seeking and reporting the truth. The precious gift of free speech and …
The News And Times
4 hrs ago
Investigations into October 7th Attack on Israel Uncover Host of Failures. Collectively, these investigations highlight a multi-layered tragedy: a catastrophic failure of Israeli intelligence and defense on one hand, and a brutal, pre-planned assault involving widespread atrocities by Hamas and affiliated groups on the other. The full legal and political repercussions of these findings continue to unfold.
Investigations into October 7th Attack on Israel Uncover Host of FailuresCollectively, these investigations highlight a multi-layered tragedy: a catastrophic failure of Israeli int…
Get updates to your inbox
The News And Times
9 hrs ago
Kadyrov and October 7 attack on Israel – AI Review
Kadyrov and October 7 attack on Israel – Google Search https://t.co/1vgghAFHvm https://t.co/5Ivj04tgqNhttps://t.co/RNGiHHt7lzKadyrov and October 7 attack on Israel.Ramzan Kadyrov, …
The News And Times
22 hrs ago
The Wagner Group – GRU Hypothesis of the October 7 Attack: This military operation was brilliantly and highly professionally designed, planned, and performed. The meticulous professional planning, technical expertise in the electronic warfare, etc. exceed the Hamas capabilities by far. These signs point to the GRU, and the GRU only, in the given circumstances. It might have been the retaliation for the downing of the Alexandrov Ensemble plane and for the use of Russia as the cover in the Israeli Operation Trump – 2016. Review of Posts as of 5.11.25
Search inside imageSurviving October 7th: We Will Dance Again review – an unflinching, moving account of Hamas’ attack | Television & radio | The GuardianVisitImages may be subject…
The News And Times
23 hrs ago
The relationships between Israel’s Mossad, the Soviet KGB, and its Russian successors (FSB, SVR, and GRU) are complex
Articles and Tweetsx.com/i/grok/share/k… The relationships between Israel’s Mossad, the Soviet KGB, and its Russian successors (FSB, SVR, and GRU) are complex, marked by a mix of p…
The News And Times
1 day ago
Blogger Michael Novakhov on October 7 – Hamas, Wagner Group, GRU, Russia connection
https://t.co/TXn4x3EndNOn October 7#NewsAndTimes #NT #TNT #News #Times #World #USA #POTUS #DOJ #FBI #CIA #DIA #DOD #ODNI #Trump #TrumpNews #TRUMPISTAN #Israel #Mossad #Netanyahu #U…
The News And Times
1 day ago
Are the fingerprints of Wagner Group, GRU, and possibly Putin behind the October 7 2023 attack on Israel? – AI: “No evidence” … My opinion: GRU (and their global brethren) do not leave the evidence, they are somewhat more professional than the street thieves. They use covers. In this case, Hamas and by extension Iran, were the natural covers and the tools. Also: AI: Mossad and KGB.
Are the fingerprints of Wagner Group, GRU, and possibly Putin behind the October 7 2023 attack on Israel? – GSAI: “No evidence…”My opinion: GRU (and their global brethren) do not…
The News And Times
1 day ago
Shadows and Spies: The Complex Dance of Mossad, KGB, FSB, and GRU – AI Review
Cold War’s Deadliest Battle: Spies in the ShadowsShadows and Spies: The Complex Dance of Mossad, KGB, FSB, and GRUArticles and Tweets | Post Linkx.com/i/grok/share/k… The relation…
The News And Times
1 day ago
Posts Review – 4:47 PM 5/10/2025
Posts Review – 4:47 PM 5/10/2025 – Post LinkThe News And Times45 min agoTrump’s first 100 days: motives, directions, policiesArticles and Tweets – Post LinkTrump’s First 100 Days g…
The News And Times
1 day ago
Trump’s first 100 days: motives, directions, policies
Articles and Tweets – Post LinkTrump’s First 100 Days g.co/gemini/share/a…x.com10mTrump’s first 100 days: motives, directions, policiesx.com12mx.com/i/grok/share/d…x.com14mcopilot….
The News And Times
2 days ago
Will Trump declare a Palestinian State? Predictive Analysis. Trump’s Middle East Policy Forecast … Trump Sidelining Netanyahu: Reports Emerge.
The Trump Plan for the Israeli-Palestinian ConflictCJPME Factsheet No. 218, published February, 2020: This factsheet provides an overview of the Trump Plan for the Israeli-Palestin…
The News And Times
2 days ago
Trump – Netanyahu conflict: events, analysis, predictions – AI Review – 7:57 AM 5/10/2025
Articles and TweetsTrump – Netanyahu conflict: events, analysis, predictions – AI Review thenewsandtimes.blogspot.com/2025/05/trump-…x.com2hRT by @mikenov: В Киеве европейские лид…
The News And Times
2 days ago
Trump – Netanyahu conflict: events, analysis, predictions – AI Review: The Trump-Netanyahu relationship is at a crossroads … This dynamic is fascinating.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a meeting with U.S. President Donald Trump in the Oval Office of the White House on April 7.Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin …
TWO LANDLORDS WHO MANAGED TO RID THEIR PROPERTIES OF SQUATTERS now face a demand of $160,000 “to relocate” the offenders.
The post Landlords sue city over liens and demands to pay for squatters’ ‘relocation’ appeared first on Brooklyn Eagle.
Some New Yorkers drink to forget their MTA-related woes, hoping to ease the pain of a long delay or sweaty subway car with a strong cocktail at the local bar.
But beleaguered straphangers won’t find an escape at Grand Army Bar. The bar’s newest themed menu is an alcoholic homage to the city’s transit system, with 14 drinks inspired by the wonders and horrors of the daily commute.
“The 242nd St./Van Cortlandt Park,” for example, is a “whiskey-based tiki swizzle” flavored with apricot, lemon, and poppyside and inspired by the Lloyd’s Carrot Cake steps from the end of the 1 train line in the Bronx. One of the non-alcoholic drinks, the “Accessible Station,” is made with spirit-free gin, papaya, guava, and dairy-free clarified coconut milk, is described as “accessible to many.”
The bar, located at the corner of State and Hoyt streets, regularly rolls out new themed menus, and this one is both a celebration of the MTA and of the bar’s 10th anniversary — Grand Army’s first-ever themed menu in 2015 was called “Trains and Railroads.”
Developing the drinks was a little more challenging than usual, said head bartender Patty Dennison.
“The thing that I want to be important and top of mind is not coming up with a drink and then forcing it onto something related to the theme,” Dennison said. “But doing some research, finding something that relates to the theme, and then creating a cocktail around that…which can be very challenging, I will say.”
But the whole team chipped in with their own ideas and mixes. They agreed that after a “tough winter,” they wanted to lean into summery flavors — lots of fresh fruit and some unexpected ingredients.
There’s the “G-train,” inspired by the taco trucks that often park outside stations along the route and made with Mexican gin, cilantro, poblano, blanc vermouth, and Gentian; or the “Manhattan Bound” — a riff on a classic Manhattan with Irish whiskey, rye, sweet vermouth, toasted coconut, and pineapple.
One bartender at Grand Army “really is passionate about public transportation being free,” Dennison said, and his drink is the “Fare Evasion,” with mezcal, Manzanilla sherry, cantaloupe, and chamomile.
For Dennison’s own creation, the “Union Square,” she thought about the fresh fruit and flowers she’d buy at the Union Square farmer’s market when she worked in Manhattan. The finished drink is a fizzy refresher with vodka, strawberry, jasmine, and blanc vermouth.
So far, the “Dirty Dog Martini” with gin, dill-infused aquavit, vermouth, bay leaf, and pickled tomato is a customer favorite, Dennison said, and the “Fare Evasion,” which described an “absolute banger,” has been a hit.
Grand Army itself is decked out with MTA-themed decor, like custom-made “Courtesy Counts” ads painted by one of Dennison’s friends.
In an era where many small businesses are struggling, Dennison said it’s “kind of a feat” for any bar to celebrate its 10th anniversary.
“I think the thing about Grand Army is that it’s been so different throughout the ten years,” she said. “Whoever’s running the program … it just kind of morphs and changes the bar in a way that’s cool. It’s just cool to be part of this iteration of Grand Army.”
SENIOR CITIZENS AND Rep. Nicole Malliotakis on the morning of Monday, May 12, rallied support to reduce taxes on Social Security income.
The post Rep. Malliotakis joins seniors as she pushes to reduce Social Security benefits tax appeared first on Brooklyn Eagle.
Van Robinson was a giant.
From his youth in the Bronx to the noble service in Syracuse that defined his career, he blazed trails for countless lives and stood tall for Civil Rights.
Today, New York State mourns a true hero. pic.twitter.com/lYc1ZlzT7S
— Governor Kathy Hochul (@GovKathyHochul) May 12, 2025